Unfortunately the exact same thing happened to me, and is unfortunately happening again even after differential replacement.


I had these issues begin several months into ownership so I began studying these threads. I brought my car in to service as soon as I realized the sounds from my LSD (Limited Slip Differential) weren’t normal.
At that time(8/2018) this was a brand new issue in the USA so Kia wasn’t even aware of the special oil and jumped directly to a full differential replacement due to metal shavings already in the oil. They had a new differential shipped in from Korea and after a week I got my car back and all was well, for a little while at least.
Shortly after I started noticing the same type of whinnying noise & shuttering in the rear end so I explored these threads again. At that time I saw forum members start posting about a TSB for special differential gear oil so I took the car back to Kia(10/2018) and explained this solution to my service advisor. They claimed they never heard of such a thing so I showed them the Australian TSB about the special differential gear oil repair. Unfortunately that didn’t matter and they sent me home without a resolution. They even stated on my service invoice “No TSB on KGIS for this concern at this time so the tech will not perform the TSB that was referred by the customer. No work performed at this time and waiting on tech line for further instructions on the repair.”
Over the next few weeks all the symptoms continued to get worse so I kept calling in for updates. They repeatedly said they were still working on it and finally a whole month later got approval from the Kia tech line and ordered the new proper gear oil. So they let me drive around on a new differential without the proper oil while the issues continued to get worse for months until they finally added the proper differential oil on 11/2018.
At that point I hoped it was finally resolved, but sure enough the same disheartening symptoms have come back again for the third time. I brought my car back to Kia(1/2019) but this time they started playing games and saying everything was operating normally. They documented “Could not replicate the concern at this time. No problem” and released the car back to me without fixing it. I argued with the service manager because I knew this was nonsense, but instead of trying to help she just accused me of driving the car too aggressively and any issues I had was my fault. This was the worst customer service I ever experienced so I asked if I could file a complaint with the GM. They said he wasn’t available and gave me some toll free number to call which just brought me to some automated Kia help line. I left furious and swore I would never return to that dealership ever again.
Unfortunately the noise, shuttering & all the symptoms you explained above just kept getting worse so I got a referral from a fellow Stinger buddy and made an appointment(4/2019) to see his dealership even though it was an hour away. To my amazement the service advisor explained to me that my previous dealership reported to Kia corporate that I abused my car so they declined warranty work on a separate ongoing warped rotor issue.

They made me pay for a rotor resurfacing myself and then reported “vehicle is operating normal. differential was replaced at an other dealership before and no repair done at this time”.
I love my Stinger but have had such a bad experience with multiple service centers I may have to proceed with a lemon law on the reoccurring differential issues, or try to file official complaints against Kia for defamation, etc. I honestly don’t know what to do and hope you or anyone else never has to go through this type of BS yourselves.