Sold my Stinger

I locked myself into my lease late Feb, literally just before the Covid stuff went into full swing. I'm currently at month 5 of "forced days off," making 75% of my pay, but luckily the "budget" dictates I only need 75% of it to just get by (with no extras). In retrospect, even though I'm happy with the car, it was bad timing lol. To all people looking at new vehicles, stay cognizant of the market lol.
 
After only about 3500 miles on it, I decided to let the Stinger go. The Carvana venture capitalists seem to be willing to pay what I paid for it, so I just had to take a loss on the sales taxes (hurts in CA). But it was worth it to get rid of a car that I just never got comfortable with. Just wanted to say thanks to everyone here! Surprisingly, I managed to resolve all major rattles with the help of all the helpful posts on the forum. I thought that fixing the rattles would be enough to make me like the car, but it just didn't happen. The power is amazing, but I realize now that I value refinement more.

I am lucky that a friend who is working from home during covid is lending me his 2012 Lexus IS350 while I hunt for my next car. While the Stinger obviously has way more tech than this previous-gen 8 year old Lexus, I am surprised at just how much more refined the IS350 is, even with a lot of miles under its belt. The Lexus is simultaneously both stiffer, has less suspension travel, but is way more comfortable. It's particularly noticeable at low speeds over small bumps. The IS 350 just feels way more "solid". The Toyota V6 is also pretty sweet, and doesn't have the Stinger drone.

Definitely not here to bash on the Stinger. I think it's a great car for the right buyer. It was my mistake for not test-driving the car more. Youtube reviewers said it was a comfortable grand tourer, but I don't think it's that.

Now onto the agonizing process of picking my next ride... So many choices!
The 2021 Lexus IS 350 is on my radar for my next car. New body and more interior room and great Lexus quality!
 
The 2021 Lexus IS 350 is on my radar for my next car. New body and more interior room and great Lexus quality!

I was excited about the 2021 IS, but it seems like a mild refresh with the same boring powertrain. I was really bummed. The new Acura TLX Type S looks pretty promising though. Not as much horsepower or torque as the Stinger but you can bet it'll likely have more refinement and attention to detail.
 
Last edited:
______________________________
I have an offer for my loaded Premium 2.0 from Carvana for about $4000 more than I owe on it and, since as of a week ago I am unemployed, she’s got to go. Love the car but cars come and cars go. Going to take off all my additions in case I get another one down the road.....maybe the 2.5 engine if they really bring it here. Very sad week here.

I hope you find Employment quickly. It sucks to hear things lime this.
 
From interior to exterior to high performance - everything you need for your Stinger awaits you...
Tough to say. I came from an X3 and am tempted to go back to one.
I have been looking at the 2021 X3 M Comp. I love them. Despite the rattles, the shitty dealers, shaky brakes, and the fact that I'm driving a KIA....there is something about the Stinger that makes me scared to sell it. I love it, but I hate it.
 
I gotta say I love my Stinger! I do believe it's where you come from in terms of cars. For me, this is my first sports car and while it's not perfect... I think it has me. I never really looked at the BMW's, Mercs, and Lexies...I just think those are for specific people. As in, they are your bag or they make you feel some kind of way and that's that. They are probably "tighter" around the edges, but they have also been in the game for a while. As far as the Toyos, I like the new Camry... from the outside, nice ride! I was about to get an SRT Charger right before I bought the Stinger, but I felt the immediate penis extension feeling when I sat in the car, just felt fake. :rofl: In any event, I just think when it comes to this car you either love the hell out it and deal with it's blemishes or you don't. It's like...it's like relationships... :coffee:

Edit: Almost left out... do your thing OP! YOU MUST BE HAPPY WITH YOUR CAR, it's an extension of sorts. :D
 
Oh... an SUV. :(
Getting old :(

I have been looking at the 2021 X3 M Comp. I love them. Despite the rattles, the shitty dealers, shaky brakes, and the fact that I'm driving a KIA....there is something about the Stinger that makes me scared to sell it. I love it, but I hate it.
I came from a 2017 M Sport 35i and it was pretty sweet. I can only imagine how insane the M Comp is now. I'm thinking of going with the plug-in hybrid this time.

I gotta say I love my Stinger! I do believe it's where you come from in terms of cars.
Yes, indeed. Had I gone straight from my old Mazda3 to the Stinger, it would have felt like the best thing ever. Sadly, I ruined my taste buds with some other cars along the way.
 
I have driven the IS350 is slow and not much refined, please define refinement... Good luck hope you find a refined car.
 
I have driven the IS350 is slow and not much refined, please define refinement... Good luck hope you find a refined car.

Slow? Sure, but there is more to a car than 0-60 speeds. My next car probably won't be a Lexus (I'd consider an F car but you're right about the IS powertrains being underwhelming) but I would definitely buy a Lexus before buying another Kia. That isn't necessarily a dig at Kia. Just that I think Lexuses are that good. Toyota/Lexus is still much better than Hyundai/Kia in the quality and engineering department, and leaps and bounds better regarding service quality (Lexus) and proven reliability.
 
______________________________
From interior to exterior to high performance - everything you need for your Stinger awaits you...
Slow? Sure, but there is more to a car than 0-60 speeds. My next car probably won't be a Lexus (I'd consider an F car but you're right about the IS powertrains being underwhelming) but I would definitely buy a Lexus before buying another Kia. That isn't necessarily a dig at Kia. Just that I think Lexuses are that good. Toyota/Lexus is still much better than Hyundai/Kia in the quality and engineering department, and leaps and bounds better regarding service quality (Lexus) and proven reliability.
Sure, but what is your definition of refinement? If you are so sure that the Kia is an inferior product I am just curious to see what objective measurements are you using or you are just using perception and subjective brand feelings.

I have had no quality problems with my Stinger its been solid no rattlers no nothing, it is engineered fantastically even the speakers were integrated into the chassis to avoid vibration, let alone the monstrous power this V6 gives you.
My local dealer has been very cordial, honest and clean, they have not damaged my car at all, I tell them not to wash the car they don't wash it, I tell them need a early oil change they do it, tell them I want to buy new wiper blades they say we will just replaced them for you just buy the part.

Again please define refinement of a car for you.

Thank you
 
Last edited:
Also Peter Schreyer, Gregory Guillaume and Albert Biermann where involved in the engineering of the Stinger so please let me know what do you mean that the Lexus IS 250 is leaps and bounds better than the Stinger?
 
That would be a reasonable conclusion but in the USA at least, it's the exact opposite. There has been a tremendous run up in used vehicle prices. There is a combination of lack of supply of new cars due to factory shutdowns, and an aversion to public transit due to health scares.


I sold my car now (for what I paid for it) because I don't believe this will hold. You'll also find another post where someone sold his car and made a few hundred dollars on it.

I should also mention that just 3 months ago, Carvana's offer for my car was $6k lower. Things change quickly!

Finally, there aren't great deals to be had right now as a buyer, both on the new and used side. As mentioned, I'm fortunate to have a friend lending me a car, and I'll probably wait at least a couple months for the market to calm down.

Carvana released their earnings report today and was greeted with a 28% pop in their already high stock price. They seem to be killing it. I'm not convinced this isn't a bubble though.

To put that into perspective, Carvana now has the same market cap as GM, and is way higher than Ford or Fiat-Chrysler.
 
Sure, but what is your definition of refinement? If you are so sure that the Kia is an inferior product I am just curious to see what objective measurements are you using or you are just using perception and subjective brand feelings.

I have had no quality problems with my Stinger its been solid no rattlers no nothing, it is engineered fantastically even the speakers were integrated into the chassis to avoid vibration, let alone the monstrous power this V6 gives you.
My local dealer has been very cordial, honest and clean, they have not damaged my car at all, I tell them not to wash the car they don't wash it, I tell them need a early oil change they do it, tell them I want to buy new wiper blades they say we will just replaced them for you just buy the part.

Again please define refinement of a car for you.

Thank you

Also Peter Schreyer, Gregory Guillaume and Albert Biermann where involved in the engineering of the Stinger so please let me know what do you mean that the Lexus IS 250 is leaps and bounds better than the Stinger?

First, I'm not trying to crap on Kia or the Stinger. I was a Stinger owner for over a year and a half, and I had every intention of being an "ambassador" for the Kia brand for years to come. In a time where car makers are abandoning the sedan and/or sportback segment, I loved (and still do love) what Kia is trying to do with the Stinger and I hope they continue to develop it and improve it over the next several years.

This is a Stinger forum, and I know that people take things personally when you start saying critical things about the cars they own and have emotion and finances invested into, so I probably shouldn't even have made my previous post.

I never said that the IS250 was leaps and bounds better than the Stinger, so I can only assume that your post above was more of an emotional response to my perceived negativity toward the Stinger than an actual response to my comparison of Lexus and KIA. I said Lexus's service and proven reliability is leaps and bounds better than Kia.

You may not have had any bad experiences with Kia, and the only real glaring issue I had during my short stint as a Kia owner had to do with the service department that damaged my car the day I bought it. There were some other issues but they were all ultimately fixed with the help of Kia of America.

With that said, if you've ever owned a Lexus (or presumably any other premium/luxury brand), the service is simply much better. Free loaners during repairs and recalls being the first main difference that comes to mind. Sure the argument is that you pay for that service with the premium brand markup, but the Stinger has a premium brand markup (if you go by MSRP). Good luck getting a loaner Stinger if you ever need to give your car to the dealership for a week. You would be lucky to get an Optima at most dealerships.

As far as refinement goes, I can only speak to my experience during the ~7k miles I drove the car in 1.5 years. You said that you haven't had any issues, so it's no surprise that you (and Merlinthemad) can't relate to the frustrations that I (and so many others on this forum) have had with the little things that on their own may not be big deals, but when added together serve to really sour the Stinger ownership and driving experience.

Feeling EVERY rubber seal squeak/tick anytime the chassis flexed when driving over a bump or graded pavement, random interior knocks and creaks, noisy sunroof, blindspots, finnicky tech (phantom blindspot monitor and parking sensor alerts), a constantly surging cruise control, very jerky braking in sport mode, etc..

Further, I don't know many $50k cars where people bought lowering springs to IMPROVE the ride (in pretty much every aspect according to users on this forum) compared to the stock Stinger suspension. Comparable feel and performance, sure, but aftermarket Eibachs being essentially used as a bandaid to fix a poorly tuned/configured factory suspension? If that doesn't scream unrefined to me, I don't know what does.

To me, refinement not only applies to the engine and transmission, it also applies to how well the individual parts and features function when assembled as the final product. Refinement was the best way I could describe it, but there may be a better term. Would saying it felt "cheap" bother you less? Because that wouldn't be too far from the truth, tbh.
 
With that said, if you've ever owned a Lexus (or presumably any other premium/luxury brand),

Bruh. Do you even know who you're talking to? This guy has owned several Porsches (garbage), Audi's (overpriced), a Lambo and a Ferrari...but for some reason always talks about how fast and luxurious the Stinger is. Also, you shouldn't need to define "refinement" to him, as he spent 12 yrs in school to become a doctor...but for some reason can't put together a proper sentence.

Seriously though, I'm in the same boat you were in. I spend quite a bit of time in my car (about 18K/yr) and I'm completely over all the rattles and squeaks. I even had my sunroof replaced last fall. My last car was a B8.5 S4 that I put 95K on. That thing was as quiet when I traded it in as it was when I drove it off the lot the day I bought it. The smart thing for me to do would be to keep the Kia for at least a few more years as I purchased the extended warranty...but I'm not exactly known for my remarkable decision making skills.
 
From interior to exterior to high performance - everything you need for your Stinger awaits you...
I never really looked at the BMW's, Mercs, and Lexies...I just think those are for specific people. As in, they are your bag or they make you feel some kind of way and that's that.

As a current BMW owner, I will say I had literally no desire for the brand prior to owning (leasing) it now. I know they are expensive and many have issues with overall reliability over the long term. I ended up in one though because the M240i was the closest thing to what I consider an ideal car for me...right now. I wanted to go back to a smaller car, have an interesting and fun drivetrain, and a good initial build quality (hopefully it holds up). So far, everything has been pretty good, the only issues are the fact it really is expensive for what it is as a package (i.e it is missing a lot of tech, which I'm sure will all be updated in the 2022 refresh of the 2 Series coupe), and you can't get manual with AWD (we have a long winter)...

Would I buy a BMW again? Not at all because of the brand name, but if they are the only manufacturer offering pretty much what I want at the time, then possibly yes. I have no favoritism to brand names, but there are a few that I'd less likely buy from based on past experience, and right now I want to see some more improvement from HKG before I give them another chance. Although I want to get back into used cars to save some money after this lease is up, if HKG has a sweet sports car, preferably one where the roof comes off, and it has quality to meet my standards, I could be in the market.

Feeling EVERY rubber seal squeak/tick anytime the chassis flexed when driving over a bump or graded pavement, random interior knocks and creaks, noisy sunroof, blindspots, finnicky tech (phantom blindspot monitor and parking sensor alerts), a constantly surging cruise control, very jerky braking in sport mode, etc..

This literally echoes the experience with my Stinger. I had incredibly high and possibly unrealistic expectations for the car, especially from the mass praise from the reviewers - in the beginning at least. When you read the reviews from the long term reviewers, you will see that a good number of them also had issues like this pop up, and their words literally parallel my experience - a pretty great driving car for the price, but with flaws. I wasn't able to see past them unfortunately.

As for noises (being the main culprit of complaints) and those who say their cars don't make a single squeak, creak or rattle, let me drive your car for a week, I bet I'll find one or two! Unfortunately, that's my talent :(
 
______________________________
I had incredibly high and possibly unrealistic expectations for the car, especially from the mass praise from the reviewers - in the beginning at least. When you read the reviews from the long term reviewers, you will see that a good number of them also had issues like this pop up, and their words literally parallel my experience - a pretty great driving car for the price, but with flaws. I wasn't able to see past them unfortunately.
If there's one thing I've learned from this experience, it's that there's a large subset of automotive reviewers that simply don't apply to me anymore. Most of them talk about squeaks/rattles as if they aren't deal-breakers. As if extra torque/horsepower makes up for it. I would never make that tradeoff so I've learned not to trust those reviewers anymore.

As for noises (being the main culprit of complaints) and those who say their cars don't make a single squeak, creak or rattle, let me drive your car for a week, I bet I'll find one or two! Unfortunately, that's my talent
I do think there are some (lucky) people for whom these noises just don't bother them. The person that is lending me his IS350 also has a BMW 530e and MB E350 Wagon in his garage (both 2019). He drove my Stinger before I returned it and thought I was silly. He couldn't hear anything and thought it was totally fine! He felt there was virtually no difference in refinement compared to his cars. That's probably why these kinds of threads end up devolving into silly arguments. We're all just different, and it's hard for the human brain to believe that another person could perceive the same car so differently.
 
First, I'm not trying to crap on Kia or the Stinger. I was a Stinger owner for over a year and a half, and I had every intention of being an "ambassador" for the Kia brand for years to come. In a time where car makers are abandoning the sedan and/or sportback segment, I loved (and still do love) what Kia is trying to do with the Stinger and I hope they continue to develop it and improve it over the next several years.

This is a Stinger forum, and I know that people take things personally when you start saying critical things about the cars they own and have emotion and finances invested into, so I probably shouldn't even have made my previous post.

I never said that the IS250 was leaps and bounds better than the Stinger, so I can only assume that your post above was more of an emotional response to my perceived negativity toward the Stinger than an actual response to my comparison of Lexus and KIA. I said Lexus's service and proven reliability is leaps and bounds better than Kia.

You may not have had any bad experiences with Kia, and the only real glaring issue I had during my short stint as a Kia owner had to do with the service department that damaged my car the day I bought it. There were some other issues but they were all ultimately fixed with the help of Kia of America.

With that said, if you've ever owned a Lexus (or presumably any other premium/luxury brand), the service is simply much better. Free loaners during repairs and recalls being the first main difference that comes to mind. Sure the argument is that you pay for that service with the premium brand markup, but the Stinger has a premium brand markup (if you go by MSRP). Good luck getting a loaner Stinger if you ever need to give your car to the dealership for a week. You would be lucky to get an Optima at most dealerships.

As far as refinement goes, I can only speak to my experience during the ~7k miles I drove the car in 1.5 years. You said that you haven't had any issues, so it's no surprise that you (and Merlinthemad) can't relate to the frustrations that I (and so many others on this forum) have had with the little things that on their own may not be big deals, but when added together serve to really sour the Stinger ownership and driving experience.

Feeling EVERY rubber seal squeak/tick anytime the chassis flexed when driving over a bump or graded pavement, random interior knocks and creaks, noisy sunroof, blindspots, finnicky tech (phantom blindspot monitor and parking sensor alerts), a constantly surging cruise control, very jerky braking in sport mode, etc..

Further, I don't know many $50k cars where people bought lowering springs to IMPROVE the ride (in pretty much every aspect according to users on this forum) compared to the stock Stinger suspension. Comparable feel and performance, sure, but aftermarket Eibachs being essentially used as a bandaid to fix a poorly tuned/configured factory suspension? If that doesn't scream unrefined to me, I don't know what does.

To me, refinement not only applies to the engine and transmission, it also applies to how well the individual parts and features function when assembled as the final product. Refinement was the best way I could describe it, but there may be a better term. Would saying it felt "cheap" bother you less? Because that wouldn't be too far from the truth, tbh.
But you still have not mentioned objectively what refinement means other than just subjective points towards how you feel about the car and kia as a company.
 
But you still have not mentioned objectively what is refinement means other than just subjective points towards how you feel about the car and kia as a company.

Pretty sure I did. See the last three paragraphs of my post. If you don't agree that what I'm describing should be considered "refinement" then that is fine - the terminology is just semantics at this point. The issues I highlighted in my post pertaining to quality still apply.
 
Pretty sure I did. See the last three paragraphs of my post. If you don't agree that what I'm describing should be considered "refinement" then that is fine - the terminology is just semantics at this point. The issues I highlighted in my post pertaining to quality still apply.
Very subjective to me... my Porsche 981 head liner has come undone due to summer heat melting the glue and its still a refined product. Your complains are all minimal and subjective in my opinion. Not because there are some minor subjective problems it means the stinger as a product is not refined product. Is like saying all porches 981 are crap becomes some of them have headliner sagging in hot weather. Peace i will sign out. Good luck with your next car.
 
From interior to exterior to high performance - everything you need for your Stinger awaits you...
Kia Stinger
Back
Top