Where do you see Kia recommend Total?
As I wrote in the post, "recommended in the manual." See chapter 8, page 7.
The good news is I found that
Pennzoil is making a next gen product called "
Platinum Euro L" which meets the same specs as Total Quarts, (ACEA C3--the highest standard) and is
available for $28 at
Walmart online. I'll be buying Pennzoil Euro L when I'm through with the Total Quartz I ordered, or whatever the cheapest C3 spec oil is at the time. The standards for C3 are so incredibly stringent, they're all going to be effectively the same from all makers.
It's also important to note that the 2.0L requires next gen oil (unlike the V6). Mobile makes an ACEA C2 spec, listed as the minimum for that engine, called Mobil 1 ESP 0w-30. It's only available in that rating, though. The US oil companies don't want to put top quality oil on our shelves until they have to (they all have top products in the shelves in Europe, due to competition). My guess is the difference between ACEA C2 and C3 would be incredibly minimal for a gasoline engine. That being said, because the 2.0L requires next gen oil, it would probably benefit more from the improvements in C3 than the V6 would. The good news is, thanks to Pennzoil, we all have a C3 option, which is cheap, for all our engines.
My guess is part of the reason the US companies don't want to bring out C3 oils in the US, is because they are all designed to last 30,000KM (18,641 miles). There are still people in the US who think they should change their oil every 3,000 miles, and Mobil would certainly prefer they continue to think that. I'll be changing my oil at Kia's recommended 6,000 mile mark, mainly just to keep the engine as clean as possible. One of the main issues we have in the US, that other countries don't, is the corn (ethanol) that's added to our gas. It's nice for farmers in Iowa, but it's corrosive to seals and creates nasty buildup in the engine. To combat that, we add detergents to our gas in the US, to try and remove the ethanol sludge that builds up. If I lived in another country, with good gas, I'd probably change my oil every 12,000 miles or so. No reason to throw away perfectly good oil. That is, indeed, part of the reason for the C3 standard, to reduce the amount of good oil people are throwing away.