That’s incorrect. You can make more power by increasing efficiency as well as adding more air & fuel. The convoluted stock air box system and very small 1”x2” air inlet connectors are extremely restrictive. This forces the engine to work harder which reduces the HP the engine can potentially make. Also if you allow more air in the ECU will adapt and add more fuel to keep the AFR within its preset range. More air & fuel simply makes more power. So between the extra air & fuel going in, and removing restrictions to make the engine more efficient you gain 15-25whp with almost any high flow open air intake.
Yes they are from vendors and likely are the best gains possible, but reputable vendors like BMS, Stillen, etc. won’t risk fraud by false advertising and showing fake HP gains. I’m also pretty sure BMS did exactly what you’re describing in their dyno test above. They filled up with 91 octane, did a dyno run on map2(389whp), then changed the filter setup to open air intakes and retested it on the same dyno right after(417whp). They did a few WOT runs in between to allow the ECU to adapt which is what uniformed users don’t do on private dyno sessions and likely why they don’t see all the real gains. There are also multiple independent users on IG, FB, etc. that show similar gains of 20whp by adding intakes.
Yes the stock intakes are sealed systems, but two things to consider why that doesn’t matter much. First, the warm engine air only effects IATs when stopped and sitting still for extended periods of time. As soon as you move warm air is drawn out of the engine bay and replaced with cool outside air.
Second, on turbo vehicles the air runs through an intercooler which significantly cools the air before entering the engine no matter what intakes you use.
A member on here did thorough testing comparing the sealed OEM intakes vs open intakes with heat shielding. He proved that the differences of IATs were minimal and all the extra airflow definitely outweighed the slightly higher intake temps.
Lastly, multiple people showed ~0.2 second drops on 0-60 & 1/4m times which would only happen with significant HP gains. So many dyno proven gains of about 20whp are backed up by real world performance, which makes intakes one of the best bang for the buck
mods(DIY only $100) you can do on our Stingers.