Body shop tried to pull a fast one

87and66

Stinger Enthusiast
Joined
Feb 11, 2019
Messages
794
Reaction score
651
Points
98
Location
Pittsburgh, PA
Story Time:

Some of you may have seen my thread in late November when I hit a deer at about 70mph. I got the car back from the body shop on December 10. They did a fantastic job... so I thought. Cosmetically, the car looked brand new. However, they took money for work that they didn't complete.

December 14, I'm in the garage looking a the car and I take a flashlight and decide to take a look deep behind the grille. (I know, I should have done this before leaving with the car. My mistake). And that's when I see it. The AC condenser and Oil cooler are still damaged. These parts were easily visible before the car was repaired. The Oil cooler was on the original estimate. The body shop added the AC condenser to the supplemental estimate after starting repair work. So they were 100% aware of the damage. They were 100% aware that they were being paid to replace these parts. And they ignored them.

These 2 parts aren't visible unless you look inside the grille with a light. I'm assuming they saw me, a 24 year old who maybe doesn't look like he knows much about cars, and they assumed I'd never notice. Bad news for them, I'm pretty mechanically inclined and cars are one of my passions. So inevitably, I noticed. There is no way it was an accident, because they were exposed the entire time the front end was being rebuilt until the bumper was put on.

To make a long story short, I contacted my insurance company and was instructed to take the car back to the body shop. The owner of the body shop, who is one of 3 people who work there, basically played dumb. They completed the repairs and the car is back to normal.

I feel like there should be repercussions for this. Hopefully Geico blacklisted them so at least they wont make any money from drivers with Geico insurance. They basically tried to steal $823.60 (cost of parts and labor). Sad part is, this shop has a perfect 5 star rating on google and that's why I went there. 17/17 people gave them 5 stars. Well, make that 17/18.

You can see the damaged (after repair) condenser in the picture. The entire oil cooler was bent in a slight U shape instead of being straight, and had a lot of damaged fins, but I couldn't get a good picture of that

Moral of the story, don't trust anyone with your car, because even a reputable shop can try to rip you off if you don't look like a car guy in their eyes.

IMG_2941.webp IMG_2947.webp
 
Thanks for the heads up. Sounds like I should bring a flashlight when I look over my car whenever the body shop is done playing with it. I won't be keeping it anyway, but better to know I'm not going to get burned down the road.
 
Tell your insurance company and they will nail the company to the wall for insurance fraud.
 
______________________________
Story Time:

Some of you may have seen my thread in late November when I hit a deer at about 70mph. I got the car back from the body shop on December 10. They did a fantastic job... so I thought. Cosmetically, the car looked brand new. However, they took money for work that they didn't complete.

December 14, I'm in the garage looking a the car and I take a flashlight and decide to take a look deep behind the grille. (I know, I should have done this before leaving with the car. My mistake). And that's when I see it. The AC condenser and Oil cooler are still damaged. These parts were easily visible before the car was repaired. The Oil cooler was on the original estimate. The body shop added the AC condenser to the supplemental estimate after starting repair work. So they were 100% aware of the damage. They were 100% aware that they were being paid to replace these parts. And they ignored them.

These 2 parts aren't visible unless you look inside the grille with a light. I'm assuming they saw me, a 24 year old who maybe doesn't look like he knows much about cars, and they assumed I'd never notice. Bad news for them, I'm pretty mechanically inclined and cars are one of my passions. So inevitably, I noticed. There is no way it was an accident, because they were exposed the entire time the front end was being rebuilt until the bumper was put on.

To make a long story short, I contacted my insurance company and was instructed to take the car back to the body shop. The owner of the body shop, who is one of 3 people who work there, basically played dumb. They completed the repairs and the car is back to normal.

I feel like there should be repercussions for this. Hopefully Geico blacklisted them so at least they wont make any money from drivers with Geico insurance. They basically tried to steal $823.60 (cost of parts and labor). Sad part is, this shop has a perfect 5 star rating on google and that's why I went there. 17/17 people gave them 5 stars. Well, make that 17/18.

You can see the damaged (after repair) condenser in the picture. The entire oil cooler was bent in a slight U shape instead of being straight, and had a lot of damaged fins, but I couldn't get a good picture of that

Moral of the story, don't trust anyone with your car, because even a reputable shop can try to rip you off if you don't look like a car guy in their eyes.

View attachment 37492 View attachment 37493
It is very sad how many crooks are out there trying to steal your money. :cautious:
 
From interior to exterior to high performance - everything you need for your Stinger awaits you...
Glad you found it.

Hope you take the time to post your experience on their Google reviews page.Scumbags like that don't deserve to be in business.
 
One word...........”COCKROACHES”:devil:
 
Well! Not being a car guy (still, at 67:p), I can't tell what that pic is supposed to reveal; I'd need a side by side comparison to educate myself. Those shysters love people like me; like they thought you were, apparently. Thanks for sharing. It's never too late, and you're never too old, to learn.:thumbup:
 
Well! Not being a car guy (still, at 67:p), I can't tell what that pic is supposed to reveal; I'd need a side by side comparison to educate myself. Those shysters love people like me; like they thought you were, apparently. Thanks for sharing. It's never too late, and you're never too old, to learn.:thumbup:
...................Merlin , you are a Stinger Guy ! Arguably.......... THE Stinger Guy !!:)
 
______________________________
From interior to exterior to high performance - everything you need for your Stinger awaits you...
I still don't know what I'm looking at half the time (that's generous). Stingers I know. Gearhead stuff, not so much! :laugh:
...................Merlin , you are a Stinger Guy ! Arguably.......... THE Stinger Guy !!:)
 
I still don't know what I'm looking at half the time (that's generous). Stingers I know. Gearhead stuff, not so much! :laugh:
So basically two “WASTED POSTS”:laugh::laugh::laugh::rofl::rofl:
 
One word...........”COCKROACHES”:devil:
I had another word , same # of letters , started with a C and ended with an S too ...........................
 
So basically two “WASTED POSTS”:laugh::laugh::laugh::rofl::rofl:
I am making an appeal to understand what the picture shows. Asking questions. However long that takes, to determine if I get what I want or get nothing. Now, that is "three wasted posts". :P
 
From interior to exterior to high performance - everything you need for your Stinger awaits you...
Well! Not being a car guy (still, at 67:p), I can't tell what that pic is supposed to reveal; I'd need a side by side comparison to educate myself. Those shysters love people like me; like they thought you were, apparently. Thanks for sharing. It's never too late, and you're never too old, to learn.:thumbup:
It’s not a great picture, but the grayish colored thing is the AC condenser. Basically a radiator that cools gaseous refrigerant and turns it into liquid. So it should look like the one pictured. Basically, not smashed haha. D2C16312-2D07-4287-8D28-E1A4E8AE640A.webp
 
______________________________
Glad you found it.

Hope you take the time to post your experience on their Google reviews page.Scumbags like that don't deserve to be in business.
I absolutely will. And that’s something I’ve never done. But I feel it’s necessary
 
It’s not a great picture, but the grayish colored thing is the AC condenser. Basically a radiator that cools gaseous refrigerant and turns it into liquid. So it should look like the one pictured. Basically, not smashed haha. View attachment 37503
Thanks.
The one that they left on your car does look bent in spots. Does that compromise the function or just look bad? Maybe they figured "if it works, okay", and pocketed the difference (as you said, pretty confident that YOU were never going to notice it anyway).
 
Thanks.
The one that they left on your car does look bent in spots. Does that compromise the function or just look bad? Maybe they figured "if it works, okay", and pocketed the difference (as you said, pretty confident that YOU were never going to notice it anyway).
Theoretically, since most the cooling fins on the top two levels were smashed, it wouldn’t cool as efficiently. But I probably wouldn’t notice any difference. There was the possibility of a leak in the future. Also with the oil cooler, there was the possibility of a leak, which would be bad. Either one having a failure down the road would probably end up costing me money. Which is not cool
 
Last edited:
Kia Stinger
Back
Top